A few weeks ago we reported that the Blu-ray Disc Association had mandated new minimum specifications for players produced after October 31. With these specs requiring increased memory and support for picture-in-picture video, many people, including myself, were concerned that first gen players would become obsolete. To find out the truth, PC World talked with Andy Parsons, chair of the Blu-ray Disc Association's U.S. Promotions committee about these concerns. In their article Mr. Parsons tries to calm the waters a bit stating "your existing Blu-ray player will continue to play future titles as it does today."
All current Blu-ray Disc players support the BD-Java spec. (BD-Java is the programming language used to design the menus and present interactive content on a Blu-ray Disc.) In fact, says Parsons, this was a requirement from the get-go: "All players introduced since day one must support BD-Java."

Already, movie titles like Chicken Little and The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen are taking advantage of BD-Java's capabilities; in both of those cases, the movie discs offer interactive games.

If BD-Java is shipping today, why the confusion? "This fall," explains Parsons, "is the end of a grace period. Any new Blu-ray Disc player model introduced after October 31 must now fully comply with the full range of existing Blu-ray Disc player specifications."
While first gen players will continue to play titles the same as they do today, PC World points out that they will not play on-demand picture-in-picture commentary nor can they access interactive functions via the internet. Unless you really need these features, its probably not worth upgrading to a second gen player. However, if you haven't bought one yet, I'd save my money and wait until fall. If you'd like to read more, the entire article can be found here. Add a comment
While many people are blaming Universal and their HD DVD/DVD combo format for the latest round of playback problems, the issue may actually be a result of the verification process. According to jimby_99 of the AVS Forum, there is no way to burn and check a disc in various players. To make matters worse, the verification software Toshiba provides does not always catch all of the bugs in the authoring before a disc is replicated.
There are two problems with making titles for HD-DVD that Blu-ray doesn't have:

1. It's not possible to make a full HD-DVD burn yet to check the entire title; you have to preview the title on an emulator, which does NOT give you the ability to QC in various players. This is a huge disadvantage compared to Blu-ray, where you can make a Blu-ray burn and run it in specially modified production players.

Without the ability to burn check discs, there is virtually no way to do proper QC...

2. The verifier software that Toshiba is responsible for is (in my opinion) not currently up to the task. For those who don't know what verifier software is...this is the software that is run when the title is received at the manufacturing plant to verify that the authoring is "legal" and to the specification. It's meant to catch specification-related bugs in the authoring BEFORE the disc is replicated.
If you're wondering, jimby_99 was the production supervisor for "Nine Inch Nails: Beside You in Time" which was recently released on both Blu-ray and HD DVD. If you'd like to read more, head on over to the AVS Forum. Add a comment
High-Def Digest has reported that Xbox 360 owners are having a hard time playing Universal's latest HD DVD release, 'Children of Men.' While this problem doesn't seem to affect everyone, many people can't play parts of the disc or in some cases, get the drive to recognize it at all.
'Children of Men' hit stores earlier this week on March 27, as one of the most highly-anticipated HD DVD releases on the format thus far, and as our Kenneth Brown wrote in his recent review of the disc, it apparently boasts stellar video and audio. Unfortunately, more than a few Xbox 360 owners have had issues playing it on the device's popular HD DVD add-on drive, with many of our readers writing in to say that the disc simply won't play, and that even multiple returns of the disc have produced the same issue.
If you check out the posts in High-Def Digest's forum, you can see that 'Children of Men' isn't the only title people are having problems with. Lets hope that Microsoft can address these issues in the next Xbox 360 update. If you'd like to read more, the entire article can be found here. Add a comment
Last week, there were reports that the HD DVD version of 'Children of Men' failed to play on some Toshiba players and the Xbox 360 HD DVD add-on drive. Apparently, these issues aren't limited to just this title. According to TheManRoom, the HD DVD/DVD combo version of 'The Good Shepherd' has similar playback issues.
A couple days ago I cautiously approached Universal's next Combo Format HD DVD with U-Control functionality, 'The Good Shepherd.' My gut suspected the disc would suffer from the same playback issues as 'Children of Men,' but given how that disc's errors have been random across various players, there was at minimum a shot for success. Sadly, my gut was correct. 'The Good Shepherd' disc failed to play on both the HD-A1 and Xbox 360 HD DVD players with the exact same error messages 'Children of Men' returned. Whether my experience will be shared by the greater HD DVD community remains to be seen; however, it's our duty to pass along this caveat to those having pre-ordered the disc or plan to pick it up on Tuesday. Keep those receipts!
Universal has not officially acknowledged these issues. However, the company has already discontinued the combo versions of some titles and has retooled a few upcoming releases to be HD DVD-only. Needless to say, this doesn't look good for the combo format or HD DVD in general. If you'd like to read more, head on over to TheManRoom. Add a comment
Sony Europe has announced the launch of its first Blu-ray Disc player, the BDP-S1E. Like the BDP-S1, the BDP-S1E features 1080p/24 output and DVD upscaling. However, unlike its American counterpart, it also supports HDMI 1.3 and x.v. Colour.

Responding to a rapidly growing market demand throughout Europe, Sony has announced the latest addition to a Blu-ray Disc family including High Definition gaming, editing and now, the ultimate home theatre experience. The BDP-S1E represents one of the company's most powerful and intelligent consumer equipment models ever developed: the player sets new standards in High Definition audiovisual playback of movies. The superbly stylish BDP-S1E integrates seamlessly within Sony's ‘BRAVIA' Theatre concept to produce one of the most stunning and engaging entertainment experiences ever developed.

Film lovers will relish 24p True Cinema incorporated into this Blu-ray Disc player. Cine cameras actually film at 24 frames per second, but televisions operate at a higher frame rate, so conversion has traditionally been necessary. The result is a 4% discrepancy from the original - the film on TV actually runs 4% faster than the original, and the soundtrack rises by 4% in pitch. When the BDP-S1E is connected to a TV with 24p capabilities such as the ‘BRAVIA' D3000 series, the original 24 frames per second are displayed just as the camera first recorded them. You see - and hear - exactly what you should, exactly as the director intended.
While Sony Europe has not announced a price or ship date yet, the BDP-S1E should hit store shelves some time this summer. If you'd like to read more, the entire press release can be found here. Add a comment